Caroline Summers is prepared for her life to drastically change when she goes home to take care of her father. But she isn’t quite ready to step directly into her past. All anyone wants to talk about is who she used to be—captain of the cheerleading squad, homecoming queen, etc. But all Caroline wants to do is prove she’s more than just the pretty, popular girl she was back then. Which is easier said than done when she accepts a job at her old high school, the site of her past glories.

As if all of that wasn’t enough, Caroline tries to keep her mischievous father from having another heart attack—and the playoff-bound Chicago Cubs aren’t making that task easy.

But, with help from the only new thing in town, Paul Winters, Caroline might just find something to like in the girl she used to be.