Tom Gabriel is asked by Giuseppe to go back to Staten Island and find out who killed his friend - the bag lady - Horty. No sooner does he begin investigating her murder, than a sniper tries to kill him. He is soon trying to keep one step ahead of the shooter as he follows the clues Horty left for someone to find. Rae goes to a dying woman's house to listen to a strange story about abducted women over fifty years, and the clues to those abductions being left in the woman's head by a man every five years. As soon as she begins following the clues, she realises the story might be true.