Was it by chance that Rachel Callahan answered an ad for help on a dairy farm in Luck, Wisconsin? Was it by choice that when Colt Shepard met her, the memories he still carried of Lizzy and the horseshoe she had given him haunted him so much that he left the farm for an uncertain future? Was it by chance that he won it all in a poker game, only to lose his freedom after a shooting cost one man his life? Was it by choice that Rachel kept up her vigil for the one man who had taken her heart? And would it be by chance that they might meet up again one day... Or would it be by choice?