Set in rural parts of Oklahoma and Colorado in the 1960s, Buffalo Brother is the engaging story of Johnny Lightfoot as he struggles to fit into the modern day society. Following a wild night out with a friend, he finds himself waking up in jail facing serious charges and consequences. It becomes apparent that his grim fate will be spending time in a juvenile facility that would be more harmful than good to the boy's development. Just as the judge at Johnny's court appearance is about to bring the gavel down on such harsh punishment, an uncle steps forward and assumes responsibility for the custody of the youthful offender. Relieved and rejuvenated the boy returns to the holding cell to bid farewell to his partner in crime only to discover heart-wrenching tragedy. And so his seemingly solitude journey to manhood begins.